Dec. 19, 1974 review: Genesis does "Lamb Lies Down on Broadway" at the Century Theater

 


“Lamb Lies Down on Broadway” lays an egg on Main Street. 

Dec. 19, 1974 

Gabriel’s Good Idea Lost in the Performance 

          “The concerts should work more like a film,” Peter Gabriel, lead singer for the theatrical-minded British rock group Genesis, is quoted in the latest Rolling Stone.

          Very much like a film was the Genesis concert Wednesday night in the sold-out Century Theater, what with that three-part screen flashing images on high while Gabriel prowled the stage as Rael, hero of the group’s new double concept album, “The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway.”

          You could call it a rock opera, too, this journey from the streets of New York City to some surrealistic hell and back by way of the Grand Parade of Lifeless Packaging.

          Like grand opera, it helped to have an idea of the libretto. But unless you possessed intimate knowledge of the new album, which lays out Rael’s entire trip in the liner notes, then Gabriel might as well have been singing in Italian.

* * *

“LAMB” PROBABLY would make a weirdly fascinating movie. As a rock stage piece, however, it was emotionless and musically mechanical, as if it had gotten permanently lodged in Lifeless Packaging.

          Passing comparisons with the Moody Blues or Yes just wouldn’t hold up. And Gabriel’s lyrics, no matter how he declaimed them, came out pretty much incomprehensible. Chalk that one up to the sound system.

          So those unfamiliar with “Lamb” were left with the slide show, the stagey flashes and smoke and only a couple costume changes for Gabriel, who in the past was putting chameleons to shame.

* * *

GABRIEL SLIPPED from his black jeans and leather jacket once to be enclosed in a spinning dragon tube which looked like a holiday float and again as a temporary monster in a balloon outfit that made him resemble a squid with tumors.

          These and his age-old number from the ages of man show (done as an encore) were the high points of the two-hour-plus set, along with Gabriel’s strutting presence.

          Nevertheless, muddied concepts do not make great concerts and slide shows are a weak substitute for a real film. Gabriel may have had a good idea, but it got lost in the translation.

* * * * *

IN THE PHOTO: Peter Gabriel in the Slipperman costume

* * * * *

FOOTNOTE: A time of extreme stress for Genesis. Peter Gabriel was leaving at the end of the tour in mid 1975, the band was deep in debt, the album’s arrival in mid-November had been greeted with mixed reviews and the staging was troublesome. Some say this helped inspire “This Is Spinal Tap.”

Genesis did the “Lamb” album in its entirety, with a couple old favorites for the encore. Here’s how it played, courtesy of setlist.fm: 

The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway

Fly on a Windshield

Broadway Melody of 1974

Cuckoo Cocoon

In the Cage

The Grand Parade of Lifeless Packaging

Back in N.Y.C.

Hairless Heart

Counting Out Time

The Carpet Crawlers

The Chamber of 32 Doors

Lilywhite Lilith

The Waiting Room

Anyway

Here Comes the Supernatural Anaesthetist

The Lamia

Silent Sorry in Empty Boats

The Colony of Slippermen

Ravine

The Light Dies Down on Broadway

Riding the Scree

In the Rapids

It

(encore)

Watcher of the Skies

The Musical Box

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

July 6, 1974 Review: The first Summerfest concert at Rich Stadium -- Eric Clapton and The Band

Image
  This was the summer that rock ‘n roll came to the brand new Buffalo Bills stadium in Orchard Park . There was a lot of official nervousness about this kickoff event.   July 6, 1974   Hassle-Free Clapton Concert Scores a Pleasant Success             Rich Stadium got its baptism in rock ‘n roll Saturday evening and it all went off so well that the home of the Buffalo Bills football team should be bouncing to the big beat for many summer nights to come.           It was a star-studded event – stars above and stars on the stage. The Band, honed to near perfection as a live act, cranked out a happy, raucous set. And guitar idol Eric Clapton, who announced that he was drunk (indeed, he was very drunk), took a laid-back set that left many of his worshippers perplexed.           But the real heroes of this show – the first of four in the Summerfest ’74 series at the stadium – were promoter Jerry Nathan and his Festival East organization. * * * THEY TURNED the near-impossib
Read more

Feb. 2, 1974: The Blue Ox Band

Image
  One of the major local rock bands of the day and predecessor to some equally wonderful aggregations down the line.   Feb. 2, 1974 Blue Ox Wants Aggressive, Bitey Sound   AS BLUE OX themselves will tell you, a lot depends on the crowd.                    One night they’ll be sitting there in the Bona Vista on Hertel Avenue like good old boys and girls on the bayou, bobbing in their private dreams to the Grateful Dead’s “Truckin.’”           A few nights later, at an even more tender hour, the tiny dance floor is full of folks boogieing their heads off to the very same tune. * * * “IF YOU LISTEN for a whole night,” guitarist-organist Charlie O’Neill says, “we go through all kinds of styles. But sometimes the slower stuff is rough when you’ve got a bunch that wants to bounce around.”           Variety, for Blue Ox, has been a matter of trading and balancing between a club crowd’s boogie urge and the band’s own preference for subtler, more complex tunes, including a fe
Read more

August 9, 1976 review: Elton John at Rich Stadium, with Boz Scaggs and John Miles

Image
  Now that all the organizational issues for Rich Stadium concerts were ironed out, Mother Nature decided to throw a curve. August 9, 1976 Elton John Pours It On For Rain-Soaked Fans Elton John was amazed. “I thank you for standing out in the rain and sitting out in the rain,” he remarked as he strode out in a Stars & Stripes Uncle Sam outfit in Rich Stadium Saturday afternoon for the first of three encores. “You deserve a medal of honor.” Instead of medals, the drizzle-soaked, wind-chilled crowd of 52,560 got a whale of a concert from the supermost superstar of the ‘70s. In fact, such was the energy of that first encore – everybody shouting along to the chorus of “Saturday Night’s All Right for Fighting” – that the rain faltered and it seemed like the sun would awaken for a guest appearance. But it didn’t. It was miraculous enough that Superfest 10 beat the deluge. The promoters rushed to fit it all in, forestalling an epidemic of rockin’ pneumonia and the boogie-w
Read more